|
SCPO Briefing Paper
6/2
Partnership Plans
Following
the election and inter-party negotiations, Labour and the Liberal Democrats
have published their Partnership Agreement detailing their programme for
government. Both coalition parties are able to claim that they have seen the
vast majority of their manifesto commitments translated into the Agreement
– partly due to the similarity of their manifestos (a feature of the
manifestos of all the main parties in the election).
A key
focus of the document is on the environment, which was a particularly strong
focus in the Lib Dem manifesto, and Labour has had all of its manifesto
targets enshrined. The major stumbling blocks – on youth crime and PR for
local government – were resolved, with the Lib Dems securing a commitment
to voting reform and obtaining some qualifications of Labour’s plans to
imprison parents who fail to control their children (which may mean it will
be virtually impossible for any parent to be jailed under the policy).
This
Briefing summarises major policies on issues identified by the churches as
priorities during the election; it also outlines the 14 Bills planned for
the first year of the new Parliament (with 4 to be introduced before the
summer recess).
- Social Inclusion
Social
Inclusion Partnerships are to merge with Community Planning Partnerships, in
a bid to make them more accountable to the local community. A target is set
for reducing the unemployment rates gap between the bottom 10% of areas and
the Scottish average by 2006. The voluntary sector is to benefit from
three-year core funding, as per the recommendations of the strategic funding
review of the sector, helping its planning and sustainability, and the
Executive plan to work with the UK Government to create a Scottish
Opportunities Fund to provide sustainable core funding.
Greater
links are to be forged between schools and the NHS to help close inequality
gaps in health, and the work already underway on providing free fruit in
Primary 1 and 2 and breakfast clubs is to be continued. Nutrition in school
meals will be improved; local authorities will be encouraged to promote
healthy eating; advertising of junk food in schools is to be banned and
reducing its availability will be a condition of becoming a health promoting
school. The Education (School Meals) Bill, rushed through Parliament
in June, ensures that entitlement to free school meals is not affected by
changes to the benefits system.
The
Education (Additional Support for Learning) Bill is designed to facilitate
access to services for children who need additional support for learning
needs. Measures include a national strategy for special educational needs, a
mediation and tribunal service, and more say for parents and carers in their
child’s education and support provision. Access to specialist schooling
will be improved while mainstream schools will continue to be used where
this is in the child’s best interest. Local authorities will be allowed to
fund specialist schools for gifted children.
An
end to so-called ‘postcode prescribing’ is promised, and free eye and
dental checks – a key plank of the Lib Dem manifesto - introduced for all
by 2007. Concessionary fare schemes on public transport, for older people
and people with disabilities, are to be extended, with a national free
off-peak bus scheme and concessions for young people. Access to transport -
including timetable information and through-ticketing schemes - will be
improved and support given to increased safety measures at rail stations and
on the roads.
Poverty and Debt
Along
with implementation of the Debt Arrangement and Attachment (Scotland) Act,
support will be given for the development of credit unions, community
banking arrangements, home insurance schemes linked to rents in social
housing, and money advice services to help those struggling with debt; there
is also a commitment to "working with the DTI to tackle harassment by
loan sharks, establish fairer credit schemes and increased protection from
excessive interest rates". The feasibility of community-based insurance
schemes, through credit unions (initially for areas at risk of flooding) is
to be investigated. The Executive will consult with the Post Office on how
it can help improve the Post Office network in Scotland.
There
will be further consultation on diligence (debt recovery) and on legislation
to modernise the laws of personal bankruptcy, which will "strike a
better balance between supporting business risk and protecting the rights of
creditors".
Racial Justice
Action
is promised on racist abuse and attacks, and the commitment to tackle
sectarianism and implement the proposals of the cross-party working group on
tackling religious hatred is reaffirmed (although – despite a manifesto
pledge by the Labour Party to work with the churches, as well as employers,
schools and sporting clubs, on tackling sectarianism – no specific mention
is made of churches or faith communities anywhere in the document). A
national language strategy will help develop and support Scotland’s main
languages, including British Sign Language and ethnic community languages.
Local councils and other public bodies are to be required to draw up a
languages plan reflecting the local community and secure status for Gaelic
will be achieved through legislation, with a consultation promised for
autumn this year.
Refugees and Asylum-Seekers
The
only mention of refugees and asylum seekers in the document is contained in
a single sentence: "we will encourage the integration of refugees into
local communities".
Community Care
NHS
trusts are to be abolished and replaced by Community Health Partnerships,
under the NHS Reform Bill; and devolved decision making is to be extended in
an attempt to empower frontline staff and give greater freedom to local
communities. The Agreement contains an assurance that local authorities will
continue to deliver existing levels of respite care. Quality and consistency
of care will be maintained through national standards, inspection and
support, in partnership with health staff and Health Boards. However, there
is no mention of the problems of the "care gap".
Housing and Homelessness
There
are pledges to provide effective support for homeless people and eradicate
the need to sleep rough. Investment in improving social housing stock and
developing a range of housing options is promised, with an extra 18,000 new
and improved homes for social rent and low cost home ownership by 2006, and
action on increasing the availability of affordable housing in rural areas.
Local authorities will continue to be encouraged to transfer control of
housing to community based housing associations and tenants’ co-operatives
with 70,000 houses to be transferred by 2006 to community ownership, subject
to the approval of tenants. Restrictions on social landlords’ ability to
contribute to community regeneration are to be reviewed.
The
Executive pledge to cut by 30% the number of households living in fuel
poverty by 2006. The home insulation and central heating programme will be
extended to improve another 4000 homes by 2006, initially focusing on those
over 80 who have inadequate heating systems; depending on the scheme’s
success it may be rolled out to other pensioner groups after 2006.
Other
housing measures include the introduction of a decent homes standard, which
will be used to establish a new energy efficiency banding system, and to
offer incentives to homeowners who make energy conservation improvements to
their homes. For house buyers a new single seller survey will be introduced
along with a common factoring scheme to encourage maintenance. Support is to
be offered to a voluntary accreditation scheme for private landlords
designed to offer tenants a uniform standard of quality assurance.
Sustainable Development
The
document states; ‘Our commitment to the environment is demonstrated in
every section of this Partnership Agreement’. A target of 40% of Scottish
electricity generation to be from renewable sources by 2020 is set,
supporting the development of wave, tidal and solar energy and other forms
of renewable energy, and encouraging participation by local communities.
There will be no further development of nuclear power stations until issues
around waste management issues are resolved, and the UK Government and
utilities companies are to be urged to strengthen the electricity grid. A
"green jobs" strategy will be created, in conjunction with the
business community.
The
Organic Action Plan will be implemented, and Scottish Enterprise is to be
asked to help develop opportunities for new products manufactured from
waste. A regulatory framework for public water and sewerage services to
safeguard both public health and the environment protection as competition
increases will be brought in through the Water Services Bill.
Economic
development policies are to be assessed with regard to their impact on the
Executive’s sustainable development indicator targets, via the Strategic
Environmental Assessment. Vacant and derelict land is to be returned to
productive use, opening up opportunities for businesses and communities.
Other measures include (a) a Freight Facilities Grant to encourage freight
carrying by rail and water (b) Green Transport Plans (c) a minimum standard
for tree planting to act as carbon sinks beside new road developments (d)
car fumes to be cut by supporting the use of emission reducing equipment (e)
support for sustainable farming and (f) the introduction of 20mph speed
zones near schools and safer walking and cycling routes to school, with a
national framework for safe walking to school - including ‘Homezones’ -
to improve safety in residential areas. Local authorities will continue to
be supported in providing park and ride facilities. A Nature Conservation
Bill is planned for later in the parliamentary year (see below), and
proposals for a new Strategic Transport Authority are to be introduced, to
improve the transport infrastructure.
Family
A
Family Law Bill is promised, presumably building on earlier consultation and
reforming marriage and divorce legislation; no mention is made of
registration of civil partnerships or other possible measures for inclusion
in this. However, this Bill is not part of the initial legislative
programme. This apart, while there are policies which affect children and
education – including encouraging parents to be more involved in their
child’s schooling, and help for children from low income families to stay
on in education post 16 – there are few specifically family-oriented
measures.
Parliament
Collective
responsibility is spelled out, stipulating that decisions of the Executive
are binding on all Ministers, and outlining mechanisms for consultation
and information sharing. There are also provisions for backbench
co-operation: "Whilst preserving the independence of the committee
system, members of the partnership parties serving on the same committee
will co-operate on the formal business and legislation of the
Executive." Any disagreements are to be dealt with through internal
party mechanisms.
Proportional
Representation will be in place in time for the next local government
elections, under the Local Governance Bill, with the Lib Dems’ preferred
system of Single Transferable Vote introducing larger multi-member wards
represented by either 3 or 4 members. Measures to increase participation
include reform of voting arrangements, with further investigation of
postal and electronic voting. In consultation with CoSLA, an independent
review into local government finance will be carried out and an
independent remuneration committee for local government will be
established. Restrictions on standing for local authority election will be
relaxed, including a lowering of the age limit for local government
candidates to 18.
Radical
changes to First Minister’s Question Time look likely after Jack
McConnell expressed his support in a letter to George Reid, the Presiding
officer. Changes to timetabling and extending the duration would allow
more input from backbench MSPs and leaders of both the smaller parties.
The FM also suggested that Convenors of Committees could question him in
public twice a year. To improve the accountability of Ministers, Scottish
Executive Questions could be done on a ‘thematic basis’, allowing for
greater depth of scrutiny.
Executive Legislative Programme
The
14 Bills to be submitted over the next year are:
- Anti-Social
Behaviour – this "flagship" Bill reflects the major
election issue, introducing Anti-Social Behaviour Orders for under-16s,
Parenting Orders requiring parents to fulfil their responsibilities in
respect of their children, tagging for under-16s, and banning the sale
of spray paint to under-16s. A draft Bill is promised in June for
consultation (with an SCPO Briefing on this soon after)
- Budget –
the annual Bill authorising Executive expenditure
- Court Reform:
Modernising Justice – improving the efficiency in the High Court,
following Lord Bonomy's report and a White Paper issued in June
- Education (Additional
Support for Learning) – see above
- Education (Ministerial
Powers of Direction) – extending Ministerial powers to intervene
in "failing schools" in order to ensure that recommendations
of the inspectorate are taken forward
- Education (School
Meals) – see above
- Fire Services
– subject to the outcome of the current dispute, updating current Fire
Service legislation
- Local
Governance – see above
- Nature
Conservation – dealing with the conservation of biodiversity,
reform of the SSSI (sites of special scientific interest) system and
building on new wildlife crime measures
- NHS Reform
– "improving the effectiveness of health services",
abolishing NHS Trusts and establishing Community Health Partnerships
- Primary Medical
Services (GP Contracts) – implementing new GP contracts
- Strategic
Environmental Assessment – see above
- Vulnerable
Witnesses – improving the way that vulnerable witnesses are
treated by the justice system and assisting them to give their best
evidence
- Water Services
– see above
Conspicuous
by their absence from the Executive's annual legislative programme were a
Family Law Bill, a Charity Law Bill and legislation to create a Scottish
Human Rights Commission; Member's Bills are proposed re the first two, and
the SSP will revive the free School Meals Bill.
|